跳至主要內容

Helmet Technology Decoded: MIPS, WaveCel, and Modern Head Protection Systems

單車生活

Helmet Technology Decoded: MIPS, WaveCel, and Modern Head Protection Systems

The helmet is the most important piece of protective gear for cyclists—bar none. Yet faced with the dizzying array of helmets on the market, from budget options to premium models, along with technical terms like MIPS, WaveCel, and SPIN, many riders find themselves thoroughly confused. This article will take you deep into the principles and differences behind modern helmet protection technologies, helping you make an informed choice.

The Limitations of Traditional Helmet Protection

Before discussing new technologies, we need to understand how traditional helmets work and where they fall short.

The core structure of a traditional bicycle helmet is EPS (Expanded Polystyrene), essentially styrofoam. When an impact occurs, the EPS absorbs impact energy through crushing and deformation, reducing the force transmitted to the head. This design is highly effective at handling linear impacts (impacts perpendicular to the helmet shell surface).

The problem, however, is that real-world cycling accidents are rarely perfect linear impacts. Research data shows that over 70% of cycling accidents involve oblique impacts—your head doesn’t hit the ground vertically but makes contact at an angle while sliding. This kind of angled impact generates rotational forces, and rotational forces are the primary cause of concussions and diffuse axonal injury.

The EPS structure of traditional helmets is nearly incapable of addressing rotational forces, which is why the new generation of protection technologies is so important.

MIPS: Multi-directional Impact Protection System

How It Works

MIPS (Multi-directional Impact Protection System) is currently the most widely adopted rotational force protection technology on the market, developed by a research team at the Royal Institute of Technology in Sweden in the 1990s.

MIPS draws its design inspiration from the brain’s own protective mechanism. The human brain is surrounded by cerebrospinal fluid, which allows the brain to slide slightly within the skull upon impact, cushioning the blow. MIPS mimics this principle: between the helmet’s EPS layer and the head, a low-friction sliding layer (typically a yellow plastic sheet) is added.

When an oblique impact occurs, this sliding layer allows the helmet shell to move 10 to 15 millimeters relative to the head, effectively reducing the rotational acceleration transmitted to the brain.

Pros and Cons

Advantages:

  • Mature technology, extensively validated through testing
  • Can be applied to virtually all types of helmets
  • Adds minimal weight (approximately 25–45 grams)
  • Reasonably priced; entry-level MIPS helmets are available for around NT$2,000–3,000

Disadvantages:

  • Some users report that the sliding layer affects ventilation
  • The plastic feel of the sliding layer may slightly affect comfort
  • Limited to a single sliding direction (newer MIPS Spherical has addressed this issue)

The Evolution of MIPS

In recent years, MIPS has introduced several advanced versions:

  • MIPS Spherical: Integrates the sliding layer between two EPS layers, eliminating the comfort issues of traditional MIPS
  • MIPS Integra: The sliding layer is integrated directly into the EPS structure, with an appearance and fit closer to traditional helmets
  • MIPS Air: Designed for high-end road cycling helmets, balancing lightweight construction with rotational protection

WaveCel: Honeycomb Cell Structure

How It Works

WaveCel is a proprietary technology launched by Trek/Bontrager in 2019. Unlike MIPS’s sliding layer, WaveCel replaces the traditional EPS inner layer with a corrugated honeycomb structure.

This honeycomb structure undergoes three phases of deformation upon impact:

  1. Elastic deformation: The cell walls bend elastically first, absorbing the initial impact
  2. Crushing: The cell structure begins to collapse, similar to traditional EPS energy absorption
  3. Shearing: Relative sliding occurs between cells, mitigating rotational forces

Comparison with MIPS

When Bontrager launched WaveCel, they claimed its rotational force protection was 48 times better than MIPS, but this figure sparked controversy in the academic community. In independent testing by Virginia Tech’s helmet ratings, both MIPS and WaveCel helmets have earned top scores, and the gap between the two is not as large as Bontrager claims.

WaveCel Advantages:

  • Integrates energy absorption and rotational protection into a single structure
  • Ventilation is generally better than traditional MIPS
  • No additional sliding layer required

WaveCel Disadvantages:

  • Currently limited to the Bontrager brand (patent restrictions)
  • Higher price
  • Generally slightly heavier than comparable MIPS products

Other Rotational Protection Technologies

SPIN (POC)

POC’s SPIN (Shearing Pads INside) technology uses silicone pads instead of a sliding layer. The silicone pads undergo shear deformation upon impact while absorbing rotational forces. SPIN’s advantage lies in higher comfort—silicone pads conform to the head shape better than plastic sliding layers.

Koroyd (Smith)

Smith’s Koroyd technology uses thousands of thermoplastic tubular structures arranged into an energy-absorbing material. Each tube crushes independently upon impact, providing more consistent energy absorption than EPS. When paired with the MIPS system, it addresses both linear and rotational impacts.

Turbine (Leatt)

Leatt’s 360° Turbine technology places multiple soft turbine-shaped cushioning pads inside the helmet. These pads can compress and rotate in multiple directions, simultaneously reducing linear impact forces and rotational acceleration.

How to Choose the Right Helmet?

Safety Certifications Are the Basic Threshold

Regardless of brand or technology, a helmet must pass at least one of the following certifications:

  • CNS: Taiwan National Standard
  • CE EN 1078: European Union Standard
  • CPSC: U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission Standard
  • AS/NZS 2063: Australia/New Zealand Standard

Fit Is the Most Important Factor

No matter how good a helmet is, it’s useless if it doesn’t fit your head shape. When shopping, keep in mind:

  • The helmet should fit snugly against the head without pressure, and should not shift when you shake your head vigorously
  • The front edge should sit about two finger-widths above your eyebrows
  • After adjusting the straps, only one finger should fit between the chin and the strap
  • Asian head shapes tend to be rounder, so choosing products with an Asian fit version will be more suitable

Budget Recommendations

Budget Range Recommended Choice Representative Products
NT$2,000–4,000 Entry-level MIPS Giro Register MIPS, Bell Stratus MIPS
NT$4,000–7,000 Mid-range MIPS/SPIN POC Ventral Air SPIN, Bontrager Starvos WaveCel
NT$7,000–12,000 High-end integrated technology Giro Aether MIPS Spherical, Smith Forefront 2

Helmet Lifespan

Even if a helmet looks perfectly fine on the outside, the EPS material degrades over time. General recommendations:

  • Normal use: Replace every 3 to 5 years
  • After an impact: Replace immediately, even if there are no visible signs of damage
  • Frequent use with heavy sweating: Consider replacing every 2 to 3 years

Conclusion

The development of helmet technology has significantly improved our riding safety. From traditional EPS to rotational protection technologies like MIPS and WaveCel, every innovation is a step toward more complete head protection.

When choosing a helmet, remember three priorities: Fit > Safety certification and protection technology > Appearance and price. A well-fitting mid-range MIPS helmet will protect you far better than an ill-fitting top-of-the-line model.

Finally, the best helmet is the one you’ll actually wear. Regardless of which tier of product you choose, putting on a helmet every time you ride is the most effective way to protect your head.

相關影片
訂閱CT的頻道

訂閱 CT Yeh,看武嶺實測與路線攻略

北進武嶺、西進武嶺、經典百K,每條路線都親自騎過,配速、爬升、補給點全部實拍實測。

467 部影片 · 累計 838 萬次觀看